I predict that we’re only seeing the beginning of Apple’s horribly botched migration from .Mac to MobileMe. I’ve been following the discussions on the Apple’s forums, and I’m not the only one with some rather serious problems. My personal issues (shared by others) include:
- Usernames aren’t necessarily carried over to Mobile Me. My .Mac ID is email@example.com. But apple has allowed someone else to register the ID firstname.lastname@example.org.
- iDisk is down, and there’s no word from Apple when it will be fixed. I rely in iDisk to keep multiple computers in sync. I store all sorts of things there such as a page of bookmarks and a password database (using 1Password). This a fee-based service, and the multi-day outage is a significant blunder.
- My fear is that when you combine the above two issues, the recovery is going to be ugly. The WebDAV configuration used to access the iDisk appears to also be hosed or at least confused.
I don’t normally think in these terms, but if I were running Apple, there are a number of people who would lose their jobs over the way the iPhone/iPod 2.0 and MobileMe migration has been deployed. I’ll cut Twitter some slack for their infrastructure problems — they’re still a startup — but Apple has no excuse. This will cost them bigtime in their efforts to penetrate the enterprise market. And I’m going to pass on buying that iPhone after all. I think I’ll just stick with my Blackberry and iPod Touch for now. I’ve lost a lot of faith in Apple over this.
Update 7/12/08 1:30pmPDT: Tried a Software Update and got MobileMe 1.1. I can know access my iDisk, but for some reason they moved it from file:///Volumes/iDisk/ to file:///Volumes/dougkaye/, so code I’ve written to use the iDisk has to be reconfigured. Still can’t login to MobileMe via System Preferences, however. Doesn’t like my auth.
6 thoughts on “The MobileMe Upgrade Mess”
Apple is a great hardware/software company. They’re still figuring out web services. Letting someone sign up for a MobileMe account using a username that is already taken for .Mac, when MobileMe is essentially .Mac 2.0 — that’s a fundamental blunder. Are you sure that is someone else’s newly-created MobileMe account? If so, they screwed up.
Sorry to hear about the problems Doug. I hope they resolve quickly for you and do right by you to compensate for the loss of time and service. I guess I was fortunate to not have those issues with my .Mac transition to MobileMe. Atleast it’s a “first world” problem and not life or death. 🙂
Mark: Yes, I know the name has been reassigned because when I try the Lost Password feature it says they’re going to send email to someone at 11thhourentertainment.com — not a domain I’ve ever heard of.
Well my MobileMe migration went ok but the fact that they changed uri’s on you is BS. I’ve other issues with the new 2.0 software – I can’t get wifi to work on my itouch – Even after erasing the itouch and a factory restore. I’d say all in all that they rolled out too many new things at once – way too many variables from a deployment standpoint…
My family plan .Mac account was migrated to an Individual plan MobileMe account. How silly is that?
I have always had a .mac email address, now when I log in it says I am email@example.com and only email seems to work. – no calendar sync, no address sync. What is going on?